Appellate Orders

Sr. No. Name of the Applicant States/UT Appeal Order No. & Date Brief of Order ­in ­Appeal (OIA) Download AR Order No. and Date, against which Appeal has been filed
41 M/s. Sai Service Private Limited Goa GOA/AAAR/01 of 2023-24/187 dated 15/04/2024

The Applicant is NOT entitled to avail the Input Tax Credit charged on inward supply of motor vehicles which are used for demonstration purpose in the course of business of supply of motor vehicle as input tax credit on capital goods. As by capitalising the motor car it is treated as asset for use in the business and therefore such motor car cannot be said to be held for further supply.The ruling passed by AAR is upheld.

(Size: 1.21 MB)

GOA/GAAR/04 of 2022-23/73 dated 06/04/2023
42 M/s. Goa Tourism Development Corporation Limited. Goa GOA/AAAR/Rectification/01 of 2019-20/2020-21/2081 dated 16/11/2021

The ruling dated 23.03.2019 given by AAAR, Goa being consistent with the extant statute, requires no rectification. Hence, the rectification application is rejected.

(Size: 1.1 MB)

GOA/AAAR/01/26-3/2018-19/4591 dated 22.03.2019
43 M/s. Goa Tourism Dev. Corp. Ltd. Goa GOA/AAAR/01/26-3/2018-19/4591 dated 22.03.2019

The ruling given by AAR-Goa being consistent with the extend statue is maintained. The appeal is rejected

(Size: 515.82 KB)

GOA/GAAR/4 of 2018-19 dated 04.10.2018
44 M/s. Syngenta Biosciences P. L Goa GOA/AAAR/02/2019-20/3071 dated 25.02.2020

The decision of the AAR Goa in the present case is consistent with and based on a fair, proper interpretation of the extend statutory provisions, and hence requires to be maintained as legal and proper

(Size: 490.66 KB)

GOA/GAAR/09/2018-19 dated 29.08.2019
45 M/s. Chowgule & Co. P. Ltd Goa GOA/AAAR/01/2019-20/3072 dated 25.02.2020

The ruling given by AAR-Goa being consistent with the extend statue is maintained. The appeal is rejected

(Size: 3.92 MB)

GOA/GAAR/11 of 2018-19/514 Dated 21.05.2019
46 M/s Federal-Mogul Goetze India Limited Rajasthan RAJ/AAAR/13/2023-24 Dt. 15.03.2024

The AAAR held that the Authority for Advance Ruling, Rajasthan has erred in not pronouncing the Ruling on Merits. The Ruling of AAR, Rajasthan dated 18.10.2022 is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the AAR to decide the application afresh on merits after considering all the questions posed by the appellant in their application dated 11.03.2022.

(Size: 1.07 MB)

RAJ/AAR/2022-23/13 dated 18.10.2022
47 M/s Federal-Mogul Ignition Products India Limited Rajasthan RAJ/AAAR/12/2023-24 Dt. 15.03.2024

The AAAR held that the Authority for Advance Ruling, Rajasthan has erred in not pronouncing the Ruling on Merits. The Ruling of AAR, Rajasthan dated 18.10.2022 is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the AAR to decide the application afresh on merits after considering all the questions posed by the appellant in their application dated 11.03.2022.

(Size: 947.46 KB)

RAJ/AAR/2022-23/14 dated 18.10.2022
48 M/s J.B. Exhibitors Karnataka KAR/AAAR/01/2024 Dated 05.03.2024

The Advance Ruling Order No. KAR ADRG 30/2023 dated 15.09.2023 was upheld and the appeal filed by M/s. J.B. Exhibitors dismissed on all counts

(Size: 5.56 MB)

KAR ADRG 30/2023 dated 15.09.2023
49 M/s. Subway Systems India Private Limited, (Now Eversub India Pvt. Ltd.) Haryana HAAAR/2021-22/ 04 Dt. 23.11.2023

The application of the appellant, being incomplete for want of deposition of requisite fee as mandated under the GST law, deserved to be rejected. Therefore, the appeal filed by M/s. Subway systems India Private Limited (Now Eversub India Pvt. Ltd.,) Gurugram-l22OO2, Haryana, not admitted. The appeal filed by M/s Subway Systems lndia Private Limited (Now Eversub India Pvt. Ltd.,) Gurugram-122022, Haryana, was disposed in above terms.

(Size: 5.79 MB)

HR/ARL/07/ 2021-22 dated 10.01.2022
50 M/s. Subway Systems India Private Limited, (Now Eversub India Pvt. Ltd.) Haryana HAAAR/2021-22/ 03, Dt. 23.11.2023

The application of the appellant, being incomplete for want of deposition of requisite fee as mandated under the GST law, deserved to be rejected. Therefore, the appeal filed by M/s. Subway systems India Private Limited (Now Eversub India Pvt. Ltd.,) Gurugram-l22OO2, Haryana, not admitted. The appeal filed by M/s Subway Systems lndia Private Limited (Now Eversub India Pvt. Ltd.,) Gurugram-122022, Haryana, was disposed in above terms.

(Size: 3.34 MB)

HR/ARL/02/ 2021-22 dated 08.12.2021