Appellate Orders

Sr. No. Name of the Applicant States/UT Appeal Order No. & Date Brief of Order ­in ­Appeal (OIA) Download AR Order No. and Date, against which Appeal has been filed
51 M/s. S P Singla Constructions P Ltd Gujarat GUJ/GAAAR/APPEAL/2024/07dt. 30.12.2024

The appellant had sought Advance Ruling on the question as to what is the time of supply for the purpose of discharge of GST in respect of mobilization advance received by it for construction services.

(Format: pdf, Size: 3.37 MB)

GUJ/GAAR/R/2022/06 dt. 07.03.2022
52 M/s. Aorom Herbotech Gujarat GUJ/GAAAR/APPEAL/2024/06 dt. 30.12.2024

1. Determination of the liability to pay Tax on Sales of Aorom Herbal Smokes – (regular flavour) as per Tax Invoice No.: AH/GST/80 dt. 07/06/2021 made to : M/s. Sonde Exim Pvt. Ltd., Lohegon – Maharashtra, regarding. – IGST.

 2. Determination of the liability to pay Tax on Sales of Aorom Herbal Smokes (regular flavour) as per Tax Invoice enclosed herewith of Gujarat Sales regarding CGST and SGST.

(Format: pdf, Size: 3.83 MB)

GUJ/GAAR/R/58/2021 dt. 29.10.2021
53 The Assistant Commissioner, Central GST & Excise, Division I (M/s. Sikka Ports & Terminals Ltd) Gujarat GUJ/GAAAR/APPEAL/2024/05 dt. 30.12.2024

Whether M/s. Sikka Ports & Terminals Limited, is entitled to avail Input Tax Credit (‘ITC’) on services procured for the operation and maintenance of Diving Support Vehicle owned by them and used by it for supplying port and terminal handling services? 

2. Whether the M/s. Sikka Ports & Terminals Limited, is entitled to avail Input Tax Credit (‘ITC’) on services procured for hiring, and for operation and maintenance of Security Patrol Vessel used by it for supplying port and terminal handling services?

(Format: pdf, Size: 4.55 MB)

GUJ/GAAR/R/57/2021 dt. 29.10.2021
54 M/s. GACL-NALCO Alkalies & Chemicals Private Limited Gujarat GUJ/GAAAR/APPEAL/2024/04 dt. 30.12.2024

Whether GNAL is entitled to claim ITC of the GST paid on the services provided by GACL in the form of agreeing to surrender/relinquish its right on leasehold property in favour of GNAL?

(Format: pdf, Size: 3.95 MB)

GUJ/GAAR/R/53/2021 dt. 18.10.2021
55 M/s. Wago Private Limited Gujarat GUJ/GAAAR/APPEAL/2024/02 dt.29.05.2024

The applicant wishes to know the admissibility of input tax credit (ITC) of GST paid on the procurement of plant and machines [mentioned in para 3- above) including the services of installation and commissioning the same in terms of the provisions of section 16 and 17 of the CGST Act, 2017.”

(Format: pdf, Size: 3.58 MB)

GUJ/GAAR/R/33/2021 dated 30.07.2021
56 M/s. Kitchen express overseas ltd Gujarat GUJ/GAAAR/APPEAL/2024/01 dt.29.05.2024

Under which Chapter, Tariff Heading and HSN, the different varieties of Flours i.e. Gota Flour, Khaman Flour, Dalwada Flour, Dahiwada Flour, Dhokla Flour, Idli Flour and Dosa Flour manufactured and supplied by applicant will attract CGST/SGST?

(Format: pdf, Size: 5.13 MB)

GUJ/GAAR/R/32/2021 dated 30.07.2021
57 M/s Payline Technology Private Limited Uttar Pradesh UP/AAAR/04/2024-25 Dated 29.09.2024

"In view of the foregoing, we made the following order. 

(i) We set aside the impugned ruling given vide UP ADRG-43/2024 dated 20-02-2024 passed by the authority for Advance Ruling against the Appellant. 

(ii) The Supply of Gift cards/Vouchers/pre-paid Vouchers are taxable as supply of Goods and the time of supply shall be decided as per Section 12(4) of the CGST Act, 2017. 

(iii) We hold that GST is applicable on the commission/discount earned in the trading of Vouchers/Coupons by the appellant and the time of supply will be the time when the Vouchers/Coupons are traded or sold. The value of service shall be the margin between the buying and selling price of the Vouchers/Coupons.

(Format: pdf, Size: 4.2 MB)

UP ADRG-43/2024 Dated 20-02-2024
58 M/s. Arthanarisamy Senthil Maharaj Tamil Nadu AAAR/09/2024 Dt.21.08.2024

The Ruling Pronounced by the AAR that the ITC is not admissible on the Rotary Parking System desired to be installed by the applicant in advanced ruling No. 07/ARA/2024 dated 30.04.2024 is upheld and accordingly, the appeal filed by the appellant was dismissed

(Format: pdf, Size: 9.6 MB)

07/ARA/2024 Dt.30.04.2024
59 M/s S.S. Traders Uttar Pradesh UP/AAAR/03/2024 Dated 27.08.2024

"In view of the foregoing, we made the following order. (i) We set aside the impugned ruling given vide UP ADRG-01/2024 dated 15-04-2024 passed by the authority for Advance Ruling against the Appellant. (ii) We hold that appropriate chapter heading for the product proposed to be manufactured is 1517 90 90 and appropriate rate of GST applicable is @ 5 %

(Format: pdf, Size: 4.65 MB)

UP ADRG-01/2024 dated 15-04-2024
60 Faiveley transport rail Technologies India Pvt Ltd. Tamil Nadu AAAR/08/2024 Dt.10.07.2024

The Ruling Pronounced by the AAR in Advance Ruling No. 125 /AAR / 2023 dated 20.12.2023 stands modified to the extent that only the actual value in monetary terms extended to the employee concerned in the course of or in relation to employment, qualifies as a 'perquisite', and it squarely falls within the ambit of entry No.1 of Schedule III of the CGST/TNGST Acts, 2017. Whereas, the car lease amount recovered in actual terms by the appellant-company while extending the facility of car to its employees, cannot be considered as a 'perquisite' and accordingly taxes under GST are applicable on the same, as it does not get covered under the entry No.1 of Schedule III of the CGST/TNGST Acts, 2017

(Format: pdf, Size: 8.74 MB)

125/AAR/2023 Dt.20.12.2023